Anthropic’s IPO left some bankers grumbling

Anthropic’s stock market debut on Thursday set a new record, overtaking SpaceX’s June listing, and the banks that ran it took home more than half a billion dollars in fees. Even so, some of those bankers are complaining in private about how the deal was run. In an exclusive on Sunday, Reuters reported that several people close to the process listed the same problems: a compressed timeline, last-minute changes, financial projections shared late and rushed document approvals.
This is the second time this year it has happened. Bankers said much the same about SpaceX’s IPO in June. Reuters sees a pattern in it: the AI companies now hold the power, and Wall Street is going along.
What bankers objected to
Inside Anthropic the offering was code-named “Project Lantern”. It had 22 underwriters, the banks that sell the new shares to investors. According to several people familiar with the matter, Anthropic told some of them to put no more than four bankers on the deal and to make sure those four were senior staff. One of them said the rule probably came from fear of leaks, and that the banks found a way around it anyway.
The leak worries had a clear cause. Anthropic first sent its draft filing to the SEC confidentially, the usual route for big tech IPOs. Weeks before the document was made public, Reuters reported many details from it.
SpaceX ran its process just as tightly. Bankers on that deal, which earned the banks half a billion dollars in fees, chafed at how closely Elon Musk’s company controlled the months-long process and how much financial and other information it kept to itself, which made it hard for advisers to do their jobs.
Who holds the power
Reuters describes a new balance of power between tech companies and Wall Street. Investors are in a frenzy to buy shares in companies like SpaceX and Anthropic, and possibly OpenAI later, because of what AI might do. That demand lets the companies do things their way. Some bankers don’t like it, but banks and investors seem to have little choice.
“These companies certainly did have some market power to tell underwriters that it’s not going to be business as usual,” said Jay Ritter, a professor emeritus at the University of Florida who studies IPOs.
Ritter pointed to one clear example of that power. In a big IPO, the banks have the option to buy extra shares from the company at the IPO price, which they can use to steady the stock after the debut. In Anthropic’s case, Morgan Stanley took the full option from the company. Banks usually earn a fee on those shares as well. According to Ritter, both SpaceX and Anthropic negotiated to pay them nothing on them.
He doesn’t expect that to become the rule. “I don’t think most companies are going to be able to demand zero spread on overallotment shares,” Ritter said. In his view, after these two deals the big Wall Street firms will go back to business as usual with everyone except, maybe, OpenAI.
Up next
Gemini plans may work in outside agents from Dec 2
Claude and ChatGPT plans already work in Hermes Agent; Gemini runs on an API key. Google’s Logan Kilpatrick on fixing that: “December 2nd we take the first step.” Would you use your Gemini plan in an agent, or stick to Claude or ChatGPT?
Related stories
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
Join the conversation
Sign in to leave a comment. It appears after moderation.

