Pentagon’s blacklist of Anthropic ruled illegal

U.S. District Judge Rita Lin in San Francisco ruled on August 27 that the Pentagon’s decision to label Anthropic a supply chain risk violated the First Amendment, The New York Times reported. Lin found that the Department of Defense acted “based on a desire to make a public example” out of the company.
Lin quoted the government’s own explanation in her order: “Defendants claim that because of Anthropic’s ‘increasingly hostile manner through the press’ and its criticism of the Department of War’s views on AI use, Defendants ‘cannot trust Anthropic to ensure the integrity of its models.’” Her answer: “Neither the Constitution nor the federal statute invoked by Defendants allows them to impose sweeping penalties based principally on Anthropic’s critique of the Administration’s views.” The government is owed deference on national security, she wrote, but its actions were not founded on any “articulable basis.”
Lin also found a second constitutional problem. Anthropic “was denied the pre-deprivation process required under the Fifth Amendment,” she wrote, CNN reported; the clause covers the process a party is owed before a penalty takes effect. She noted that other parts of the government kept working with Anthropic, which she said was not consistent with a genuine fear of sabotage.
Lin had ruled for Anthropic once before. On March 26 she granted a preliminary injunction in a 43-page ruling, finding the government’s actions likely amounted to unlawful retaliation, according to Tech Policy Press. At a July 30 hearing she said the administration hadn’t produced enough evidence to “really justify” the ban.
A supply chain risk designation says a company threatens U.S. national security. In Anthropic’s case it barred defense contractors from using the company’s technology in their work with the Pentagon. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s post announcing it said: “Effective immediately, no contractor, supplier, or partner that does business with the United States military may conduct any commercial activity with Anthropic,” as quoted by Built In. Anthropic was the first American company publicly given the label, which CNN says had previously been used only for companies seen as connected to foreign adversaries.
The dispute began with contract talks over how the military could use Claude. Anthropic wanted assurance that its models would not be used for fully autonomous weapons or domestic mass surveillance; the Pentagon wanted unfettered access across all lawful purposes. Tech Policy Press’s timeline has Hegseth giving Dario Amodei a deadline of 5:01 p.m. on Friday, February 27, and has Trump ordering federal agencies to stop using Anthropic’s products that same day, when Hegseth also designated the company. CNBC dates the designation to March.
Trump said in a June interview with Axios that he had previously viewed Anthropic as a national security threat but no longer believed it was, CNN reported.
“We welcome the court’s ruling that this supply chain risk designation was unlawful,” an Anthropic spokesperson told CNBC. “We remain focused on working productively with the government to harness AI for our national security so all Americans benefit from this technology.” Anthropic has said the suits aim to return its business to where it stood before the designation; they would not require the Pentagon to start working with the company again. CNBC notes that Anthropic has shown no signs of slowing down since the blacklisting as it heads toward what is expected to be a near-record IPO, and that restoring ties with the Pentagon could reopen business that had been cut off.
The Pentagon relied on two distinct designations, and each had to be challenged in a different court, so Anthropic filed suits in San Francisco and in Washington, D.C., both on March 9, per Tech Policy Press. On April 8 a three-judge D.C. Circuit panel denied Anthropic’s request for a stay, citing “weighty governmental and public interests on the other side of the ledger,” including forcing the military to keep dealing with an unwanted vendor “in the middle of a significant ongoing military conflict.” The D.C. case was still open when Lin ruled, and until it is resolved, Anthropic technically remains a supply chain risk.
Up next
Hy4 Preview appears on Hugging Face under Apache 2.0
Per a Threads post, Tencent’s Hy4 Preview is up on Hugging Face under Apache License 2.0, a Mixture-of-Experts flagship listed at 770B parameters with 49B active and a 1M context window.
Related stories
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
Join the conversation
Sign in to leave a comment. It appears after moderation.

