Mathematicians recall an OpenAI promise it isn’t aware of

OpenAI is preparing to release more than 100 new solutions to unsolved math problems, WIRED reported on October 6. Mathematicians who met with the company in August say it promised not to release the solutions all at once.
The August meeting brought together about 40 mathematicians to discuss what to do if AI outpaces human capabilities in the field. People who attended say OpenAI hinted that its models had solved hundreds of long-standing problems. They also say the company was worried about how the community might react and asked for advice on how to publish the findings. They add that company representatives assured them the solutions would not all come out at once.
“There’s a perception of mobster behavior” from leading AI companies, one mathematician told WIRED.
In October 2025, Kevin Weil, then an OpenAI vice president, posted on X that GPT-5 had found solutions to ten previously unsolved Erdős problems and had made progress on eleven others. Thomas Bloom, who maintains erdosproblems.com, explained that GPT-5 had produced no original proofs. It had found existing solutions that were already in the literature. He called the announcement “a dramatic misrepresentation”, and Google DeepMind CEO Demis Hassabis called it “embarrassing”. The post was deleted within days. The next big claim held up better. On May 20, 2026, OpenAI announced that an internal reasoning model had produced a counterexample to Erdős’s 1946 unit distance conjecture. A companion verification paper co-authored by nine external mathematicians came with it, and Bloom was one of the nine.
In September, current and former Caltech mathematicians wrote in an open letter that verifying an AI lab’s claimed proof is work that “goes uncompensated, uncredited, and unacknowledged.” OpenAI then said an independent advisory group of mathematicians would weigh in on how it assesses and communicates new mathematical results.
OpenAI spokesperson Lindsay McCallum says the company is “not aware of” any assurance that the solutions would not be released all at once.
Up next
Claude gets a sidebar in Google Docs, Sheets, and Slides, Video
Every edit can wait for your approval before it lands, since Claude sits in a sidebar inside Google Docs, Sheets, and Slides and rewrites the open file in place. The beta covers all paid plans.
Related stories
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
Join the conversation
Sign in to leave a comment. It appears after moderation.

