Skip to content

OpenAI

OpenAI blames Apple’s offboarding in trade secrets fight

4 min read

Written by an AI model from the linked sources and checked against them by a second model. How we work

All about: OpenAI models and products →
Image: rswebsols.com

Apple and OpenAI face each other in court on Wednesday, when U.S. District Judge Edward Davila in San Jose hears Apple’s bid for a preliminary injunction over alleged hardware trade secret theft together with OpenAI’s motion to throw the case out, Rswebsols reported on October 15. Granting the injunction would not settle the case: it would bar OpenAI from using any confidential material allegedly taken from Apple, and from seeking more, only while the litigation runs, and OpenAI’s dismissal bid rests on its argument that Apple names broad categories of hardware information instead of specific secrets.

OpenAI’s defense leans on Apple’s own offboarding. It says an authentication mishap let Chang Liu, a former iPhone engineer who joined OpenAI in January and is named in the suit, keep access to Apple material after he left. Apple answers that what sat in Liu’s personal iCloud account is “distinct” from its main allegation, which concerns a different route into its systems.

What Apple wants stopped

Apple sued in July, naming OpenAI, its hardware chief Tang Tan and Liu. The complaint, captioned against Liu, Tan, OpenAI Foundation, OpenAI Group PBC and io Products, the Jony Ive hardware company OpenAI bought, alleges a conspiracy to extract product design, manufacturing processes, component technologies, testing methods and supply chain details. Apple says OpenAI is using that knowledge to “catalyze its ventures into the consumer hardware marketplace.”

The injunction request turns on job interviews. Apple says OpenAI used interviews with its current and former staff to pull out proprietary knowledge, and that OpenAI executives told candidates to bring prototypes and other “design artifacts”. The complaint, as TechCrunch and CNBC described it in July, says Tan, a 24-year Apple veteran, asked candidates to bring “actual parts” for “show and tell” sessions and coached departing employees on getting past Apple’s exit security checks. It also accuses OpenAI of asking hardware partners to use a metal finishing technique Apple invented while misleading a partner into believing Apple had given permission.

Davila has already moved on part of this. On October 13 he ordered OpenAI to speed up its production of documents tied to the alleged misappropriation that could benefit its upcoming hardware products.

Why OpenAI wants it dismissed

OpenAI argues that Apple never identifies a particular trade secret and that the suit only lays out general classes of hardware development information. It calls the case an attempt to stop employees from moving to rivals, one that recasts “routine job interviews as acts of trade secret theft.”

The rest of OpenAI’s filings put Apple’s security and HR practices on trial. OpenAI says Apple encouraged staff to use personal iCloud accounts for work, and that Apple employees kept opening content in Liu’s personal iCloud after he left, asking him to help find files and answer technical questions. In August it published excerpts of his messages with Apple colleagues about past projects. Those exchanges, together with offboarding that let Liu keep access, undercut Apple’s account of how he came to hold the disputed information, OpenAI argues.

Apple’s core claim is about its network storage. It alleges Liu found he could still reach Apple’s cloud-based storage through a then-unknown authentication bug and exploited it instead of reporting it. Per CNN and TechCrunch, Apple also says he never returned his Apple-issued work laptop and downloaded “dozens of Apple’s confidential hardware-related files”.

From an exit to a hearing

  • January 2026: Liu leaves Apple for OpenAI.
  • On or around February 9, 2026: by Apple’s account, Liu uses the authentication bug to reach Apple’s network storage.
  • February 2026: Apple sends OpenAI a letter raising its concerns and, it says, gets no response.
  • July 10, 2026: Apple files Apple v. Liu, 5:26-cv-07078, in the Northern District of California, San Jose Division.
  • August 2026: OpenAI publishes excerpts of Liu’s messages with Apple employees.
  • October 13, 2026: Davila orders OpenAI to expedite document production.

The employee traffic also runs the other way. OpenAI alleges in a separate filing that a staffer who came from Apple and went back after six months sent over a hundred highly confidential files on at least one unreleased device to his personal accounts on June 2, his last day.

The dispute comes after a two-year partnership that built ChatGPT into Apple’s software; relations cooled once OpenAI moved into hardware, and Apple’s updated Siri is based on Google’s Gemini models. It also lands as OpenAI aims for a $1.4 trillion valuation ahead of a public offering. Bloomberg News reports that OpenAI’s first consumer device will be a doughnut-shaped smart speaker expected to sell for over $300, which people inside the company describe as an AI-focused product distinct from anything Apple is about to unveil. In an October filing, OpenAI put it this way: “OpenAI harbors neither the need nor the desire for Apple’s proprietary information.”

No comments yet. Be the first.

Join the conversation

Sign in to leave a comment. It appears after moderation.