Round Hill sues Anthropic and Suno, damages could top $1B

Round Hill Music has filed separate copyright suits against Anthropic and Suno in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, Gadgetreview reported on August 20. Round Hill is an independent publisher whose catalog reportedly includes “Iris,” “Total Eclipse of the Heart,” “Lola” and “Holy Diver.” Both complaints allege the catalog was used without permission to train AI systems: Claude in one case, Suno’s music generator in the other.
The headline figure is $1 billion. It is a projection of statutory damages, not a sum named in either filing.
The Anthropic complaint claims at least 500 Round Hill-controlled songs went into training Claude, including works tied to James Brown, The Kinks and the Goo Goo Dolls, per Reuters and Bloomberg Law. The Suno suit alleges the same kind of infringement against its music model. Statutory damages are an amount per work set by law, so a plaintiff can recover them without proving actual losses. They run up to $150,000 per work when infringement is found willful, Music Business Worldwide notes.
At that ceiling, the 500 songs named so far support only $75 million. Music Business Worldwide put the same figure on the music publishers’ first suit against Anthropic, filed in October 2023 over around 500 works with potential damages of around $75 million. Round Hill says it may amend both complaints to cover 10,000 or more compositions and recordings.
Both complaints also bring claims under the DMCA, the U.S. law that protects technical access controls on content and the data attached to a work. They allege circumvention of access controls and removal of copyright management information: the author, title and ownership details that travel with a work.
Anthropic has been in court over how training material was obtained before. In Bartz v. Anthropic, Judge William Alsup held that Anthropic could train its models on copyrighted content but could not obtain that content through piracy, and the company settled with authors for $1.5 billion. Anthropic’s position on training itself is on record in a spokesperson statement carried by Variety:
Training generative AI models is a transformative fair use — as the court held in Bartz — and we will defend ourselves robustly.
Round Hill is not the first publisher to sue Anthropic. UMG, Concord and ABKCO filed a second suit on January 28, seeking more than $3 billion in potential statutory damages over alleged infringement of more than 20,000 songs. That suit alleges Anthropic’s founders downloaded millions of pirated books via BitTorrent, songbooks among them, and that Anthropic keeps infringing by training newer Claude models without authorization.
Suno already faces suits from major record labels on similar claims. Variety reports that music companies have moved back and forth between lawsuits and licensing, often suing before striking deals: WMG has settled its cases against Suno and Udio, Universal has struck a deal with Udio while still pursuing Suno, and Sony remains in active litigation against both. Observers suggest, Gadgetreview writes, that if Round Hill’s theory survives motions to dismiss, the informal “train first, license later” approach could become legally untenable.
Round Hill says it won’t take the settlement route. CEO Josh Gruss told Reuters the company intends to take both cases to trial and will not accept any resolution that leaves songwriters and artists undercompensated.
Up next
Concise output style lands in Claude Code
Claude Code’s new Concise output style leads with the result and keeps responses short, per Anthropic’s post on X, with full detail still coming back when you ask. It switches on under Output style in /config.
Related stories
- Anthropic’s piracy chats enter music copyright case
- Elvis Presley rights holders sue Anthropic over 274 songs
- Sony and Warner Chappell sue Anthropic over lyrics
- NEINhorn copyright suit lands on OpenAI
- Anthropic asks full D.C. Circuit to rehear Pentagon case
- D.C. Circuit calls Claude’s refusals a supply chain risk
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
Join the conversation
Sign in to leave a comment. It appears after moderation.

