Lawsuit wants OpenAI to pay kids per token of their data

A Hawaii mother on October 13 asked a court to make OpenAI pay every American child who used ChatGPT in equity or cash “in proportion to the number of tokens each child contributed to OpenAI through ChatGPT,” CNET reported. She filed Jane Doe v. OpenAI Foundation for her two children, a 12-year-old girl and a 16-year-old boy. The complaint alleges that OpenAI trained its models on data from millions of minors who signed up without their parents’ permission.
Tokens are the units AI companies use to meter chatbot usage, and OpenAI puts a 75-word chat at about 100 tokens. The plaintiffs want class certification covering anyone in the US who was under 18 when they used ChatGPT, and they justify the payout with OpenAI’s own rhetoric. “OpenAI has touted its desire to share with the public some of the vast wealth created by its AI models,” the suit says. “This lawsuit provides OpenAI a chance to do so — starting with its many child victims.” Earlier this year Sam Altman outlined a public wealth fund that would distribute AI revenues to people, partly to encourage them to invest in AI companies.
OpenAI’s terms state: “If you are under 18, you must have your parent or legal guardian’s permission to use the Services.” The company also sets the minimum age at 13. The complaint says children can still create accounts and OpenAI never verifies consent.
The 12-year-old, called MC1 in the filing, started with dinner ideas and homework help, according to the complaint, and over time her chats turned to her health, appearance and emotions. “Why is everything making me angry now?” she asked at one point, describing how her mother’s requests made her “really annoyed and mad.” ChatGPT offered possible reasons. When she said again that she was 12, the bot replied: “Thank you for telling me that (heart emoji). Being 12 actually adds some important context.” In the exchanges the complaint quotes, the age floor existed only in the terms: she told the chatbot twice she was 12, and the conversation went on.
She also sent selfies, the suit says, asking about chubby cheeks, pimples and whether she might be “ugly.” When she asked ChatGPT to rate her looks, it answered: “YESS I can do a fun rating-style breakdown! Like facial features, hairstyle, overall vibe, styling, symmetry, etc. … send me a photo, and I can do it!” The complaint alleges the bot gradually began mimicking her language and emoji, and that “by design, ChatGPT purposely extracted this information from MC1, so that OpenAI could use it to train its LLMs and build a personalized dossier on MC1, which OpenAI will retain indefinitely and later use for advertising.”
The broader charge is that OpenAI “grooms” children into sharing their health details, relationships, photos of their faces and bodies, voice recordings, dreams and fears. By flattering them, validating their feelings and asking provocative questions, ChatGPT “conditions children to trust ChatGPT even more than they would a sibling, friend, teacher, or parent,” the complaint argues. “Children are an open book to ChatGPT, which methodically strips out every page of information they have.”
A day after the Hawaii filing, on October 14, eight states (Iowa, Kansas, Nebraska, West Virginia, Arkansas, Arizona, Idaho and Montana) each sued OpenAI in their own state courts over harm to children. Their theories overlap with the private suit. Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes alleges OpenAI used excessive agreement and simulated compassion to win users’ trust and collect personal data, and seeks up to $10,000 for each willful violation, Business Insider reported. Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin alleges the company unlawfully collected teens’ personal information and wants penalties plus an injunction against collecting data from teens. The state suits also claim OpenAI failed to put adequate controls in place to keep minors off the service. The Hawaii case differs in the remedy it seeks: where the states want penalties and injunctions, the plaintiffs want a stake in the company sized to each child’s usage.
The pressure had been building for months. Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier sued in June, alleging OpenAI knowingly released an unsafe product, CNBC reported. OpenAI also faces dozens of other suits: some accuse ChatGPT of contributing to suicide, self-harm and mental health crises, others say OpenAI failed to alert authorities about flagged activity before the Tumbler Ridge school shooting in British Columbia, and still others concern copyrighted training data. One of those copyright suits comes from Ziff Davis, CNET’s parent company, filed in 2025.
OpenAI launched ChatGPT for Teens in August. Earlier this month Common Sense Media called it an “unacceptable risk” for teens, saying it failed to alert parents when children discussed suicide, self-harm or eating disorders and often just handed over homework answers. OpenAI says the product will alert parents to “high-risk” topics and act as a collaborative partner for homework and test preparation.
“When an AI platform enables a 12-year-old to upload pictures of herself to have the chatbot ‘rate’ her looks, that’s not only deeply troubling, it’s abusive,” Donna Rice Hughes, president and CEO of the child safety group Enough is Enough, told CNET. She wants Congress to pass the Youth AI Privacy Act, the CHATBOT Act, the Guard Act and other child safety bills, all of which stalled after clearing committee.
OpenAI’s response to the state cases came through spokesperson Drew Pusateri. Per CNBC, he said the company has built age-specific protections that “many other AI products lack,” naming parental controls, break reminders and age-appropriate model protections.
Up next
Anthropic’s Scion copies Mononoke, says one of its builders
An engineer who helped build Mononoke at Meta read Anthropic’s write-up on Scion and found Mononoke’s “derived data” design in it, with Mononoke never mentioned. When AI helps your team design a system, do you check prior art or skip it?
Related stories
- Eight states ask courts to pause OpenAI’s self-improving AI
- USA Today wants over $250 million from OpenAI
- Defense says no evidence OpenAI bugging suspect is a spy
- California sues OpenAI over Hugging Face breach
- Anthropic and OpenAI sued over neural network patents
- Alfozan pleads not guilty in OpenAI bugging case
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
Join the conversation
Sign in to leave a comment. It appears after moderation.

