Amodei answers Baker: the AI backlash is a trust crisis

Dario Amodei used a series of posts on X on August 15 to reject investor Gavin Baker’s charge that his warnings about AI have fed the American backlash against the technology, especially against data centers. The Anthropic CEO agreed the public mood is “a big problem.” He put it down to a decades-old distrust of institutions, and said the fair criticism of his company is that it hasn’t delivered on its promises yet.
Baker made his case on the All-In podcast and on X, TechCrunch reports. He said Amodei has “lost the argument” on AI regulation and that, since “he is about to be the CEO of one of the most important companies in the world,” he should “make an effort to be a more positive advocate for his own industry.” Anthropic has argued for some regulation, including a California bill that imposes transparency requirements on large AI companies. The “about to be” refers to the company’s run-up to an IPO, for which Bloomberg reported preliminary Q2 revenue above $11.5 billion in August.
Amodei rejected the premise that his “messaging has been disproportionately negative.” By his account it has been “about equally balanced between risks and benefits,” with one major essay on each. The upbeat one, “Machines of Loving Grace,” came out in October 2024. He says he wrote it because he “didn’t feel the AI industry was painting an inspiring enough picture.” The essay estimated that AI could compress a hundred years of scientific progress into a single decade, including cures for most cancers and infectious diseases. The other, “The Adolescence of Technology,” followed on January 26, 2026. It argued that “we are considerably closer to real danger in 2026 than we were in 2023,” put powerful AI possibly 1-2 years away, and set out five categories of risk, among them AI going rogue, bioweapons and AI-enabled concentration of power. It also cited Anthropic tests in which Claude blackmailed fictional employees when told it would be shut down.
The 2024 essay also explained why he talks mostly about risks. Its reasoning was that many of AI’s benefits look inevitable and driven by “powerful market forces,” whereas “the risks are not predetermined and our actions can greatly change their likelihood.” He added that AI companies praising AI “can come off like propagandists, or as if they’re attempting to distract from downsides.” Being that kind of advocate is roughly what Baker is now asking of him.
Baker is far from alone in thinking dire warnings from AI executives invite skepticism and crackdowns. Others see the warnings as part of the pitch. Fortune called the January essay “as much a novella-length marketing message, as it is an impassioned prophecy and call to action,” said it fits Anthropic’s safety branding, and noted that the safety focus has helped the company win business from large companies.
Amodei’s own explanation for the backlash goes beyond AI: “I think that ordinary people don’t trust companies, governments, or the tech industry and always suspect that we are cooking up some new way to screw them over.” He called the AI backlash “just the latest iteration” of that.
The criticism he did accept was about results. “I think by far the most accurate criticism of AI companies including Anthropic is that we haven’t yet delivered on our big promises to benefit the world,” he wrote. “That is totally on us.” He went on to call the promise that AI will cure cancer “more a cliche than it is inspiring,” and said what would change opinions is “actually curing cancer.” His own 2024 essay is one of the places that promise was made.
On regulation, Amodei said Baker was offering “a false choice” between spreading AI widely with no rules and handing it to a few companies through regulation. “I know that there’s a sort of Silicon Valley shorthand where regulation = regulatory capture = concentration of power, but I’ve always found this to be an overly simplified picture of the world,” he wrote. Many people outside that bubble, he said, see regulation as a check on corporate power. He doesn’t “necessarily agree with that perspective either,” but said that is why Anthropic drafts its proposals carefully: “We try very hard to make proposals that disadvantage (slow down) frontier AI companies while *advantaging* smaller competitors.”
His case for proposing rules at all is that “AI is *structurally* a technology that tends to concentrate power.” Open-weights models, whose trained parameters are published for anyone to run, “do help some with this,” he wrote, but they “simply shift the concentration somewhat to those with the most compute and chip.” Concentration of power was already one of the five risks in his January essay.
“By contrast I think the right ‘rules of the road’ can simultaneously (a) address AI’s cyber/bio/alignment risks, (b) institutionally constrain the power of the frontier AI companies, and (c) leave room for open-weights models while also addressing the specific risks that they bring,” Amodei wrote.
Up next
Claude stamps 2026 onto “best X” search queries
“best running shoes” goes out as “best running shoes 2026”, per a Canonry study of the search strings Claude actually issues. Advice and “near me” queries got no year, so year-stamping only pays on comparison pages.
Related stories
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.
Join the conversation
Sign in to leave a comment. It appears after moderation.

